Don't Look! - Part 2 of 5 (Patreon)

A small sound escapes Sophie's lips as she turns away from you, fumbling to put her top back on.  “Oh my god! Don't just stand there staring!” she half yells and half whispers.  Probably so her mom won't hear.

You step in towards her and shut the door behind you.  Probably not what Sophie was implying, but you can't resist the urge to know more.   She looks like she wants to crumple up into a ball.

“Hey, relax!” you say in a reassuring voice.  “Sorry to barge in on you, but I thought you were in your bedroom . . . why did you leave the pool so suddenly?”

“It's too embarrassing!” Sophie says, averting her eyes.  Gently, you bring your hand to her chin and pull her gaze back towards you, with a smile that says everything is okay.

"I knew my swimsuit was going to be a bad idea,” she began.  “I just really liked the way it fit on me, and really wanted to impress you.”

“Yeah. You did that, all right!” you say with an easy laugh.

“Well, I was getting . . . horny, and . . . .” she says, her face turning red as she drifts off.
“So,” you finally say, a long pause of your own, “you've always had a dick?”  You realize immediately it sounded more sarcastic than you intended. 

Sophie can't seem to speak, and just nods as she continues to stare off.  With a deep sigh, she says in a despondent voice, “I was born a freak.”

“Hey, now!” you say with your arms out to your sides.  “I've known you forever, and I think your beautiful.”

Sophie timidly looks up to you and says, “Really?  Even though I've got a dick?”

You smile and nod.  “I would never have thought about it, but I think it looks incredible on you.”

Sophie seems to relax then and smiles.  “I've always really liked you, too!  Maybe, I just didn't realize it until recently.”