Home
Artists
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register
Partychan Matrix ThePornDude
Home Artists Posts Import Register

Boys Planet EP 10 Reaction (Patreon)

Published:
2023-04-08 06:25:56
Imported:
Tags:

Videos

  • 196981664.mp4

Downloads

Content

Rest of the performances lets gooo!! Also, now that we are SO CLOSE to the finale, who is your 1pick??

Note: Reminder that next week's upload will be delayed due to my family reunion and should be uploaded the following week before the finale.

Comments

Dan

I actually was kind of upset to after this episode. They didn’t show Seungeon’s part change and vocals, Yujin’s rap-making(he wrote a line), Hanbin’s leadership, Jiwoong challenging new concept🥲

Dan
>>105907430

And they just choose to show us this drama, not talents and practice process…… Maybe for every single group🤦🏻‍♀️

wony

my 1 pick is Gunwook. he was in wild idol before and he already proved himself that he can sing, dance, rap. boys planet was a stepping stone to his debut because his growth is insane. he’s even a lyricist now. hes so talented.

cynthia li

My one pick is Zhang Hao - my complete ride or die, in that if he's not in the group I wouldn't be able to be even a casual fan because my heartbreak would be too great

Kai Leon

Sung Hanbin is my 1 pick, theres just something special about him

GreenDragon

My one pick is Yoon JongWoo. People might hate me for this (they certainly did over on Reddit ;) ) but I think Over Me made a mistake voting him out. If you've watched any of his pre-show dance vids you know he'd slay the sensual concept.....so maybe that's the point that the others were worried he'd take away some of their spot light. But if they wanted the strongest team he would've been a better choice. I found Jeong Hyeon, although good, unmemorable. He does not stand out to me, especially when he's up against Hao for capturing attention. I finished the vid and couldn't even remember if they kept his rap part because I was focused on the other members. Jongwoo is great at sing/talk rap, and an amazing strong but sexy dancer.

Summer

My 1 pick is Jiwoong!

Dan

Jiwoong is my 1pick!

cynthia li

I am so frustrated about the Over Me storyline because it just continued the erasure of Kuanjui. Like, I was already pissed off with them not showing Kuanjui's musical section, since he was the only All Star that wasn't shown AND I am so curious how he got the All Star by playing the Prince when his partner Taerae did not get the same ranking. THEN, you have such an easy and obvious storyline for Over Me, since Zhang Hao and Kuanjui worked together to choreograph the pair dance (confirmed by both of them to the audience for the third mission, they are credited for choreography in the title card, and the original choreographer Bengal Park posted the original choreo which shows that the Killing Part had a solo dance break). So, you've got a perfect storyline here - you have the bit of Haojui tension with Kuanjui being anxious about his screentime, Hao struggling with how to highlight each member + juggling suggestions, and then they resolve it by working together to create a pair choreography which, IMO, is one of the standouts of the performance? And they ignored it completely???? Like, I am Zhang Hao biased, I admit that. I think it was fair to show him struggling a bit with being more decisive, but at the same time, he did make all of the members shine and the pair choreography was an integral part of that??? I'm also very fond of Kuanjui so seeing how he was completely shafted this episode was heartbreaking. You could visibly see how desperate he was to get the benefit, because he knows it was his only chance of survival. To see him be ignored even after all of that was absolutely depressing.

SB

matthew was is n will always be my 1pick HE NEEDS TO DEBUT FR

eve_ss

Although I'm sad I'm not even mad that JAY got the last place because everyone in Over Me Team did so well but he definitely deserved higher score than that! I agree with you like atleast 600pts would do I can't believe these audiences! The latter part of the song made it for me and JAY literally did almost all the adlibs there! He basically carried the song imo. and we can see the other trainees shocked reactions when he got his scores they look disappointed as well. When JAY said that he already expected it because no one cheered for him that made me soooo sad 😞 (PS I'm still pissed with Mnet for cutting him out of the frame while he's doing his high note. Thats literally one of the highlights of the song! Fortunately they changed it on the uploaded full ver in YT and they included him.) Also, that partner dance of Zhang Hao and Chen Kuan Jui was supposedly a solo dance break for the center (Zhang Hao) but they changed the choreo. Zhang Hao really helped all his members to shine. He's a great leader!

Eurone

Ricky killed it in ‘Over Me’ ! Even before the show started he had this aura that fits those type of concept so much, the way he presents himself, the rnb vibes, I’m really glad we managed to vote him into this song ! I can’t stop replaying his fancam haha.

an ♡

It’s so hard to vote for just one person 😭 But I have two devices so I might vote for two people (Taerae and Gyuvin)

Madina F

My 1 pick is Matthew!

Irieezy. (edited)

Comment edits

2023-11-24 07:25:04 My 1 pick is Jay. His vocals are TOO GOOD to not vote for. How dare Mnet cut out his high note when he carried the vocals in that song? I watched his fancam and all his notes were flawless but they cut to the audience screaming. 🙄 even in the booth he didn't get any camera time like wtf? So irritated
2023-11-24 07:25:04 My 1 pick is Jay. His vocals are TOO GOOD to not vote for. How dare Mnet cut out his high note when he carried the vocals in that song? I watched his fancam and all his notes were flawless but they cut to the audience screaming. 🙄 even in the booth he didn't get any camera time like wtf? So irritated
2023-04-08 07:51:53 My 1 pick is Jay. His vocals are TOO GOOD to not vote for. How dare Mnet cut out his high note when he carried the vocals in that song? I watched his fancam and all his notes were flawless but they cut to the audience screaming. 🙄 even in the booth he didn't get any camera time like wtf? So irritated

My 1 pick is Jay. His vocals are TOO GOOD to not vote for. How dare Mnet cut out his high note when he carried the vocals in that song? I watched his fancam and all his notes were flawless but they cut to the audience screaming. 🙄 even in the booth he didn't get any camera time like wtf? So irritated

cynthia li

This is just a thought that's been nagging at me - am I the only one who thinks the Switch choreo looks like it was made for 7 people? I just feel like some of the transitions and positionings look awkwardly spaced when there's 6 of them. This isn't any criticism against the guys - they did great - but just a feeling I've been getting from watching the choreo itself

Eren Jaeger

yessss finally!!

eve_ss

My one pick would either be JAY or WANG ZI HAO! 💗 JAY is an amazing vocalist. He's definitely a a great main vocalist material. He's a decent dancer. He's just a slow learner but he's actually good and has nice groove. I love the texture and tone of his voice. My fave actually! 💗 WANG ZI HAO is undoubtedly the best dancer on this show. He can also sing and rap. He's an ACE. Just sad that he's not given a proper screentime. He's actually so captivating! and Idk if it's just me but he sometimes reminds me of JENO (NCT)! 💚

GreenDragon
>>105909271

yeah I felt it too, but I'm not a dancer so I wasn't sure if it was a valid thought.

Samantha Guldemond

I do have al lot for who i would like to see debut, but i think my number 1 is Park Hanbin or TaeRae.

lasgin99wif

My one pick depends on the next elimination. If seunghwan makes it through I will be voting only him. Otherwise I’ll be rotating between my faves Taerae and PHanbin

Andreeeea

My one pick is definitely Zhang Hao but i might rotate between him, Ricky and Jay

Malin Stalheim

Zhang Hao is my 1 pick! This boy needs to debut. I love his vocals and dancing and he is damn stable when performing. He has great leadership skills and I love his relationships with the other trainees, especially SHanbin and Yuehuaz

Eces24312

It's Jongwoo all the way for me. Hopefully he'll make it through 🥲

Dan

And I don’t know about other countries, F4 fans has a certain clear 1pick biases in Korea. It’s just that they are just united. It’s not just about voting them as a group. But I agree with you that their one pick vote could be weaker.. since till now their fans voted for eachother, but now they can’t…

keya

keita is my 1 pick!

Matt Vesliño

I think this episode was so fun! Definitely much better pacing, and overall less (but still noticeable) manipulative editing going on. I'll definitely be streaming all of the songs on Spotify, lmao, they're all BOPS! As for my one pick, I think I'll be rotating too. While I want Sung Hanbin and Zhang Hao on the final line-up as much as anyone, I *think* I don't need to vote for either of them, knowing how big their respective fanbases are. I honestly might rotate between Haruto, Seunghwan, Park Hanbin, Keita, Junhyeon, Zi Hao, and Gunwook. I know I should probably stick to just a few of them to rotate between, but I love all of them so much 😭 If I could only vote for definitely just ONE of them though, it has to be Haruto. King of perseverance, and we need a representative of girlypop in the final line-up 😭

Juan Mireles

Jays vocals are actually in a lot of the song, i feel like its lost because the camera isn’t on him. Or its him singing but they are showing a different member. I loveeeed this song but honestly performance and overall how they edited this performance was very disappointing

Eren Jaeger

about the duo part of over me stage, according to the instagram story by the choreographer, it was originally one member dance (killing part), but i think zhanghao and guanjui changed that into a pair duo (which was sooooo BEAUTIFULLY EXECUTED). the beginning card of this song also wrote zhanghao and guanjui names on the "participation in choreo" part.

Juan Mireles

I started watching boys planet from seeing jays vocals on TikTok (sad to see the amount of false accusations he gets). I stayed because i fell in love with Matthew and i honestly thought he would be my one pick but again because of his vocals Jays going to be my one pick!

cynthia li

Everyone is free to do whatever they want, but just a friendly reminder that no one is really safe until their name is called in the final! Especially for the top ranked contestants - they've had a lot of filler votes so far so we can't actually gauge their OP bases. In particular, I've seen a very popular voting strategy be Shanbin + Hao + their actual pick, so their current votes will be very inflated. Maybe I'm too traumatised by Yurina and JR not making it in their respective seasons lol, and Sunoo somehow dropping from 1st to 8th (thank god for the producers pick). Historically the most popular contestants suffer the biggest drops in the final because everyone thinks they're safe 😭 My motto is 'the second you drop your one pick is the second they drop out of the top ranks' and that's how I deal with any potential guilt lol.

mikaela

Jay is definitely my one pick

Violet Joo
>>105912843

Yes I am traumatized too. I voted so hard for JR and he didn't debut. After that I stopped voting in the other Produce shows.

Eren Jaeger

can't wait to see your reactions to over me practice video!! I watched that video at least 100 times before this episode aired.....

lolieqosy

Gunwook is my one pick 😍😍😍

ddarui7

Zhang Hao is my one pick

Jo

My one pick is Jongwoo, really hoping he makes it through

Violet Joo

Mine is Sung Hanbin

wony
>>105913648

taste!! he’s so underrated in these replies hehe

Doyoungismyult

This entire episode made me mad. The way Jay was treated was horrible, but what can I expect from MNET. 🙄 I was looking forward to “Over Me” the entire week. The performance was ruined because MNET did not even focus on Jay during his high note….

eve_ss
>>105915731

Same!! Today, Mnet just released reaction videos of the trainees for all the performances and the trainees were all praising JAY the entire time and not even a single reaction was aired on the actual episode! This also explains why they're all genuinely shocked after Mnet revealed his low score. 😞

candle!

i agree with you on the taerae correction scene! like it rubbed me the wrong way when youngjun master was correcting taerae to slide in without actually telling him the type of slide he was looking for in the first place🙄. Like its obvious and even mentioned by YJ that taerae doesnt catch choreo fast so...why wldnt he show taerae how to do it...and expect taerae to just magically know what hes looking for...

eve_ss
>>105909263

I agree! and he did all that while dancing!! His stability tho 🙌🏻💪🏻💯

Verner Cole
>>105912843

I totally agree with you that nobody is safe. I completely understand the temptation to vote for your no 2 if Shanbin or Hao is your no.1. It's because it's so tempting that its so dangerous because a lot of people are probably feeling the same way.

goblinmoodi (edited)

Comment edits

2023-11-24 07:25:04 gunwook and jiwoong all the way !!
2023-11-24 07:25:04 gunwook and jiwoong all the way !!
2023-04-08 12:20:47 gunwook and jiwoong all the way !!

gunwook and jiwoong all the way !!

wooyo

my one pick is KIM TAERAE🫶 also, istg those ducks have more screentime than some of the trainees🤣 for the performance, En Garde or Say My Name should have won for me, everyone just shone and it was very well balanced☺️

Verner Cole

I have a theory why the scores were so much lower this round. Its the second time they've used the same scoring system so people have had a chance to get wise to it. You can upvote or downvote each member and I'm guessing your final score is the upvotes minus the downvotes. If the most important thing to you is that a certain member ranks first to get the benefit then it makes sense to downvote all the other members. Same applies to the team votes assuming that works the same way. You don't need that many people doing that to significantly reduce the scores.

mochisung

wang zihao..🥲

Sarah Mae (edited)

Comment edits

2023-11-24 07:25:04 My 1 pick is Sung hanbin 😍
2023-11-24 07:25:04 My 1 pick is Sung hanbin 😍
2023-04-08 12:47:27 My 1 pick is Sung hanbin 😍

My 1 pick is Sung hanbin 😍

Ran1998 (edited)

Comment edits

2023-11-24 07:25:04 jiwoong and zihao
2023-11-24 07:25:04 jiwoong and zihao
2023-04-08 12:48:57 jiwoong and zihao

jiwoong and zihao

Michael Park

Jay is my absolute 1 pick. He should be the main vocal of the group :)

Ivy

junhyeon’s my 1 pick but might rotate with keita & matthew too!!

candle!

Regarding Shuaibo's situation, idk if this was already mentioned to you by someone else during the episode it happened. But its said that someone who works around cjemn found out that, that clip of him "supposedly talking shit about Woonggi behind his back" was a clip that was taken out of context yet again by mnet's evil editing which was that, apparently the staff have not been treating the chinese trainees well by not translating alot of whats going on, leaving them clueless, so though in that clip that was aired in the episode, (as someone who's a native chinese speaker i wont completely defend Shuaibo and say that what he did wasnt wrong), like he definitely said those things, BUT it was never clarified WHO he was talking about, so im guessing he was complaining about how the staff havent been translating things to them and leaving it hard for them to communicate and understand what was going on. But because he was speaking out about the poor treatment, the staff were unhappy with that, therefore leading to the major evil editing of their already tense situation. Though its been proven that the cjemn person was a real staff and n not just some troll who was blindly defending Shuaibo, you can still take everything with a grain of salt since its the internet, like Shuaibo should definitely have had a better attitude when it came to actually trying to put in effort into the stage, he was at fault as well, claiming that Feel Special was his favourite song, yet not knowing what it means😭 but i just think that the situation was definitely blown out of proportion which led to alot of people just being opening xenophobic towards him and it had come to a point where its genuinely concerning because, people are saying that during the actual recording, there were people in the crowd yelling racist/xenophobic slurs to Shuaibo whilst he was on stage, and also sending him r*pe & d**th threats its a genuine safety hazard now...

candle!
>>105919833

i just wanted to clear the situation because it still seems like you have some ill feelings towards Shuaibo's "supposed treatment' towards Woonggi but its been a known fact that mnet doesnt favour chinese trainees. So far many of the evil edits have been of chinese trainees, it can be the major things like what happened with krystian or shuaibo or even little tidbits like kuanrui, they've been consistently cutting his screentime, even in this episode, there were a total of 5 trainees who did well for the little prince musical segment, but kuanrui was the only trainee out of the five that didnt get his part shown...its these little things that rub me the wrong way about mnet's treatment and favouritism towards K and G group...

David

Could someone enlighten me on the timing for the voting? So for example I only got to see Jay perform on Friday 7th when the subs were at 100% around midday. If I’m seeing this correctly voting ends at 10am KST which would be 1am GMT on the 7th. Now, I know I would vote Jay so I could do it before then, but let’s say someone is unsure and would only vote after seeing his performance, wouldn’t that make it impossible to do for the English speaking countries? Please let me know if I’m wrong as I’m just trying to understand how it works 😊

Irieezy. (edited)

Comment edits

2023-11-24 07:25:04 He improved so much but snake ass mnet giving him less and less screen time every episode 😭😭 i saw a vid of him at his fan meeting and he was so cute I hope he knows he has a lot of support from international fans 🩵
2023-11-24 07:25:04 He improved so much but snake ass mnet giving him less and less screen time every episode 😭😭 i saw a vid of him at his fan meeting and he was so cute I hope he knows he has a lot of support from international fans 🩵
2023-04-08 14:40:42 He improved so much but snake ass mnet giving him less and less screen time every episode 😭😭 i saw a vid of him at his fan meeting and he was so cute I hope he knows he has a lot of support from international fans 🩵
>>105909263

He improved so much but snake ass mnet giving him less and less screen time every episode 😭😭 i saw a vid of him at his fan meeting and he was so cute I hope he knows he has a lot of support from international fans 🩵

Jennifer
>>105921850

If you want to watch the performances before voting, I believe they post the performances after the live show on YouTube. What I do is watch the live episode with the live captions so that I can watch the performances before the voting ends. The captions aren’t perfect, but they’re good enough to understand —people put links of the live show with the live eng sub on Twitter right after the live for people who are not able to watch it during the actual time slot of the show, but want to watch it while waiting for more accurate eng sub and/or before voting closes. Side note: voting takes place everyday (during voting periods), just mentioning it in case you don’t know.

Irving

My one pick will definitely be JAY, so I was actually really looking forward to this episode but was so disappointed on how they treated Jay , like no screen time and even with his Adlibs that were amazing they focus on the other trainees dancing instead when with all the other stages their was a reaction to the high notes and not only that the only comment about their performances from the judges was they making fun of him…. Wth. I’m glad that at least I’m the full cam on yt they show him more including his high note

Alex P

My one pick is Jay.

Seán

My one pick is Wang Zihao. If he makes it this round, I can see him bahiyyih-ing his way into the top 9, so I think mnet is trying to prevent that. And what I mean bahiyyih-ing is like how hiyyih kept ranking relatively high but never in the top 9 because only her fans were voting for her and general viewers weren't but because she was never a filler vote, her one pick caused her to make it into the top 9 in the finals even though she never entered it before. SO I really hope Wang Zihao just makes into into the finals.

eve_ss

1:53:52 Yes, that's correct. The singing parts cannot be changed or re-distributed like what Jongwoo said. However, the dance parts can be changed. They did it with Supercharger as well. From what I've heard, Zihao actually re-choreographed some of the parts to better fit the members but ofc Mnet did not show it on the broadcast 😞 Disappointed but not surprised.

Mary Zeballos

My one pick is Taerae. He is a singer-songwriter who wants to become to idol, He is so charming, and a good vocalist, but I am afraid of his one pick in the final, until this round you can voted for 3 trainees and I know several fans who did not have him as a one pick voted for him, so he has a lot of filler votes. His international fandom is very small, if we compare him with trainees like Jay, Hui, Gunwook, Ricky or Keita (who have ranks that endanger Taerae's position) I don't want to trust his Korean fandom either, because on certain Koreans portals like dc inside/ nate /pann. Taerae gets hate because they don't like his visuals, his vocal color is too old and he's not that skilled at dancing, He is occasionally called a landmine. In girls planet,Myah in the final she obtained the 4th highest vote of Korean votes, but because her international votes were low she did not debut, the same thing happened to the girl who was ranked 10th, she had the 6th highest Korean votes, but because of her Low international votes, she didn't debut, Also her low rank because mnet revealed during the final who were competing for the 9th place, that made the fans vote for those people and they managed to debut and made that girl's rank go down. In the final, votes are worth much more, even 7 times more, so it would be good if you have a one pick that you want to debut that you watch the final live and vote for him in the live show. That's why I'm worried about Taerae's situation, he doesn't have enough international one pick votes, I'm afraid he won't debut, the company he's in was supposed to debut their trainees but in the end they canceled the debut and sent them to boysplanet, even one of the trainees from the same taerae company that participated in boysplanet and that it was already eliminated, he already left the company. That company is not going to debut them, I don't know what taerae will do if he doesn't debut on boysplanet. He deserve debut

Mari

Say my name is actually charting really well in Korea for a song that’s not from a debuted group! Mnet would be kinda stupid to not make a OT9 version of it with the debut group haha Also my 1Pick is Jiwoong, he just HAS to debut!

redpandahao

So for the Over Me performance the dance break was originally a solo part meant only for the Killing Part member but Zhang Hao shared it with all the others. It's so sad that wasn't mentioned on the episode because I think it would've really shown just how well he did as a leader. Zhang Hao and Kuan Jui choreographed their duo dance part themselves (you can see their names in the credits at the start of the performance) with Hanbin helping them for the tutting part.

Hanni`Choi

My 1pick will be Ricky or Jay when the final voting starts. My fixed picks are SungHanBin, Matthew, ZhangHao, Ricky, Jay. I think Jay and Ricky are not sure in the final debut team. The other 3s are always in the top 9. That's why I will vote Ricky and Jay. I also worried about Matthew coz of mnet editing ep 9, 10 🙂. I hope my top 5 make it to debut team( Hanbin, Matthew, Jay, Ricky, Hao). Another funny thing... I want a lot of G trainees in the debut team because of Mnet. Msnake not want a lof of G trainees in the debut. I want Msnake 🐍sad🤣🤣. There are also same stories in previous Girls planet. A lot G trainees are very popular and talented. But Mnet did evil editing to some strong characters, not gave screen time to some talented trainees, especially Chinese girls. at the final, there are only 3 G girls on the debut 😒. Here, there are a lot of talented trainees in K and G. But I hope mnet do fair to all of trainees. What Mnet did in ep 9,10. They cut Jay vocals, did selfish story to Matthew, KuanJui, not give screen time to Hiroto, wangzihao ... 😒😒😒. If Mnet dont want to give screen time to G trainees, I'm okay. But dont do evil edit. ♥️♥️ all of these kids came to Korea for their dreams. They need love, not hate or attack. Sry for my long comments. Also is 1st time commenting here 😅. Not good at writing in eng.

Mbet

My one pick is Jay! It's honestly been just such a tiring journey watching this show as a Jaystar. I really can't tell if he'll make it to the final group or not. Hopefully, he'll make though... No! I NEED him to make it!

mac

Will be switching between Jay and Seunghwan for my picks!! I just can't let go of either of them 😭 Also FYI to Matthew picks, Knets are burning him hard(er) since this SMN drama began so just a heads up in case you're switching between multiple picks too. He might drop ranks.

eve_ss
>>105912843

I agree! I'll forever be traumatized of what happened to Jonghyun (JR) too. That was so painful to watch. So we really can't be complacent about the ranks this time. No one is safe!

Anika Bhattacharya

JAY NEEDS TO BE MAIN VOCAL OF THE DEBUT GROUP. i was looking forward for Jeff to seeing how freaking talented Jjay's vocals were in this performance, BUT MNETS STUPIDITY, barely even showed him during his high parts and ad libs and during this episode which was such an idiotic move. AND HIS SCORE HAD MY JAW DROPPED, HE DESERVED SO MUCH BETTER!! I can't wait for u to see the Over Me dance practice Jeff, it's AMZING AMAZING AMZING!!!

Estherlynn Lubin

My one pick is Jay! He just needs to debut.

David
>>105921850

Ah I understand now, thank you very much for the insight xx

Ann

my one pick is haruto 🥹

Shishka

I have a 2-pick, Keita and Gunwook... Cant really let either of them go so Ill probably rotate or steal my bfs phone to vote for one on each device haha

Deiseree

I'm with on you on Say My Name. I just fell in love with the song! I downloaded it as soon as it came out. And Key saying the performance reminded him of their old days reminded me of their Replay and Juliette performances during SHINee's early days. Can't wait for the finale. Oh and my one pick will always be Sung Hanbin!

pr37

I think my first pick would be Jay if I could only choose one. I just feel like he really gets overlooked but his voice is so beautiful and he has such a sweet personality. There are many people though that are amazing on this show so really hard to pick. Watching key here as an MC really makes me want SHINee to be mentors!!! I would love to see them come in as producers or mentors on a show because I think all of them have so much knowledge to share and I think they would be really good at it!

April

I think my one pick would be Jay but there’s so many I wish could debit but ik they prolly won’t get the chance for this geoup

rk2000

It's sad seeing Jay's confidence disappear slowly throughout this show from the hate he's been getting; there's such a difference from his energy during his audition & love me right performance vs after. I hope, even if he doesn't debut in Boys Planet, he still has the confidence to continue trying to debut and be a performer- cause them vocals deserve to be heard <3 :'

Line

Maybe I’m way off base here, but I have a feeling that mnet only shows last places when they either don’t care about the trainee, or they want their ranking to go down. We don’t know who placed last in Say My Name, but they made sure to let us know Jay and ShuaiBo were downvoted by the crowd lol

aicrylic (aimee)

Haruto, Jongwoo and Jay are my top 3... I really don't know what I'm gonna do when I need to choose my one pick for next voting. I want them all in the final 9 and that's definitely not gonna happen. ☹️ and little rant on Jay... it's kinda clear mnet don't want him in the final group. They cut away from his one big moment in Over Me (the high note). You know it it were a trainee they wanted there would be 50 replays of the high note and 50 different reaction cuts... (LMR moment anyone? maybe they wanted him back then and then changed their mind...) like I'm so salty, he did so amazing. I heard on twt that live audience had a hard time hearing his adlibs so that's probably a factor but also seeing him talk about having not a lot of people cheering for him was... 😭

cécile

My one pick would be park hanbin but at the same time i really want keita to make it to the top9 so ill probably do twice phanbin and once keita and rotate that way, idk if thats smart tho cause phanbin's rank is lower and he was never in the top9 but...

Maddie Ash

personally i think the criticism they gave to zhang hao as a leader was unfair, the first 7 days he was not the leader (it was jongwoo) so it’s unfair he got criticised for the lack of training the details after 7 days imo. he had little time to practice formation after the group halved ( i don’t understand about the set formations either tbh) and he was taking in everyone’s ideas - i honestly think if the interim evaluation was later on their formation problem would be solved.

Maddie Ash

over me team had jeonghyeon in the credits for the song for writing his rap and zhang hao and kuanjui in the credits for the choreo for creating their dance break - fans on site said that zhanghao mentioned that shanbin helped them with the tutting part too

GreenDragon
>>105912843

I also don't think rotating votes is a good strategy as well. I know it's hard to choose, but ideally you should pick your ride or die and go with it.

GreenDragon
>>105917275

I also heard rumors of a lot of anti-fans being in attendance deliberately not voting for certain members.

GreenDragon

My unrealistic ideal situation is that Phanbin, JongWoo, Haruto, Keita, Kamden, Jay, and Zihao all say f@%$ this show and form the most amazing group that gets signed and debuts immediately becoming a global hit!

Maddie Ash

my one pick is lee jeonghyeon !! it’s sad he’s only started to get screentime and recognition recently bcos he honestly could be really highly ranked if he was shown from the beginning :( but it he gets eliminated next week i’ll either vote taerae seungeon or sung hanbin as my one pick !

Linz

Jongwoo will forever and always be my one pick. I’ve rooted for him for so long (way before boys planet) and he really deserves this chance. 🖤

hayun lee

1 pick is hui! it got cut from the episode but en garde got a crazy amount of encore cheers. there's a reason why every round the performance that gets the best on-site reactions is whichever team hui is the leader for! the people who watch them live always agree that no one comes close to his level vocally, not to mention he's a good dancer, producer, vocal director, leader, and all the trainees really like him too. having him in the final team would definitely elevate the quality of their live stages tenfold.

wooyo
>>105916911

we just really need to keep pushing and promoting him and he needs to get more screentime next ep:(

metal_craft

I find the decision to split the performances into two episodes unfair. There are only 5 so they can realistically fit them into 1 episode. In gp999 they actually fit all the performances into one episode so it is possible for mnet to do it.

Mac

Hi Jeff - regarding the changing of the formations for the Over Me team. One of the rules for this round was that the contestants had to create choreography and take part in re-arranging and producing the song (they announced that in episode 8). They weren't allowed to change the line distribution - which was what Ma Jing Xiang wanted - but as long as they respected that they could make changes to their parts and had to make changes to the choreography. That's why Wumuti was creating the dance break for Switch before he got eliminated and why the rapper from the Over Me team changed a section of his part into a rap that he wrote himself. That's also where the Dance Master's criticism of the En Garde team was coming from last week. He didn't think they'd messed anything up. He was upset because they'd had a week to practice and were clearly not struggling to learn the dance (since they did it fine in the practice) but despite those advantages hadn't created their own choreography. That's why he asked Junhyeon if he'd created any of his own gestures and then said "It's been a week" when he said he'd just copied the original - they hadn't done an important part of the assignment even though they had a lot of time (compared to the Switch and Super Charger teams).

An Le

I am one of those people that just joined since your dance practice reaction. Hi, hehee. Anyway, I am a Zhang Hao fan so I also have a lot to explain to your reaction/point about him being the leader. I do agree with your opinions and appreciate your consideration on how it could easily be edited on mnet part but anyway, there’s a few things: 1. People are saying that Zhang Hao divided part of his killing part solo dance into a dual dance with Guan Rui (the platinum hair guys who was having different opinion with Jay in the edit) to give him more time to shine, because the original choreographer posted on their Instagram account the full killing part solo dance and there wasn’t a dual part. So I’m guessing they have to change some formation due to this. About why are they allowed to split the part when it’s supposed to be fixed, I also have no idea. 2. I do agree about if they have a full week, details should be there already. But I just want to point out that the whole previous week that they practiced, the leader for the group wasn’t Zhang Hao. He only became a leader for short amount of time after the previous leader left the group (which like you said just could have been off by 1 person). This is what people forgot because of the way Mnet edit the whole thing and blame that whole week of practice on Zhang Hao’s leadership. And this also the only song out of 5 songs that involve prop (the ribbon) in the choreography which I think would make it a little more difficult to get the details right. 3. I also want to add that Zhang Hao mentioned in the BP press conference that he had never been a leader prior to Boys Planet. In Kill This Love, he was in the same group with Keita who has good leadership. And in Tomboy, he was in a group with Sung Hanbin (another one with great leadership) and Hui who is very experienced. In this Over Me, majority of the member are very young and not having a lot of experience + Zhang Hao was just became a new leader when he and the group was used to practice under another leader => which makes the whole things happened. Feels free to correct me since I am Zhang Hao fan so my opinion could be biased.

aicrylic (aimee)
>>105947707

also, anyone else see this tweet about Zhanghao's hair clips being used to see edited footage.. what a legend https://twitter.com/xuraee/status/1644547426714521601?s=20

Hannah

So my one pick is Zhang Hao. He already has a massive fanbase so I might vote for others who I also really want to make it to the debut group too, but, I don't know... a lot of people might also think this way and it might put him at risk. The other trainees that I wanted to vote for was Seungeon and Park Hanbin. There are already trainees who for sure will debut that are good vocalists but I think Seungeon's vocals will be a great addition. A main vocal material. For Hanbin, like what you said, he'd be a great leader or performance leader and he's also reallyyyyy talented. I might probably just rotate my votes haha. GOSH I CAN'T BELIEVE THE FINALE IS IN 2 WEEKS(?) it'll be so sad to let the other trainees go. they're so talented T.T I hope they'll get to debut after this show

Ilynn

Actually I come to your patreon because of Boys Planet I wanted to know your reaction and im so happy because I enjoy it. My #1 pick is Sung Hanbin he deserve it! all rounded and very talented man he is!

lasgin99wif
>>105965194

I'd still recommend voting for your fave! A similar situation happened with Sunoo during I-land where he constantly ranked very high and so during the final his fanbase thought "let's vote for others who might not be as popular" and he ended up almost not making it, had it not been for the producers picking him.

nessy

my one pick is park gunwook!! i hope he'll be in the final line up he deserves a spot huhu he's such an all-rounder T-T

Linh vu

My one pick is Sung Hanbin. I am in love with his vocals, visuals, DANCING, and personality. My 2nd and 3rd pick would be Park Hanbin (I admire his leadership and dancing a lot), and Jay since we need a vocalist like that in the kpop industry.

Thao Pham

My one pick is Sung Hanbin❤️ But I really want Gunwook to make it too. But I think I’m gonna keep voting for shanbin because I really hope he’s able to keep his number one position!

Line

My one pick is… I don’t knoooow! Between Haruto, Jongwoo, Zihao, and Jay 😫 i’m just gonna rotate if all of them survive. Sadly, three of them are in dire situations right now and I fear for their lives.

geunyang

Have you heard of Wild Idol? It was another survival show with Gunwook (and Kamden in the first half). Can you react to it too please?!

Siti Aishah Haque

My one pick since the beginning is lee hotaek which we know as hui. But same as you I will rotate my vote also to hanbin,jongwoo,zihao and keita if none of them getting eliminate this is my pick,but we see next week..I really hope my jongwoo and zihao not getting eliminated.. anything possible can happen in one day of votes

GreenDragon

Don't rotate your one pick. I know it makes you feel good to give everyone a little something but this is how others sneak in. Pick your ride or die and stick with them! Especially if your fav is not a Korean fav because there will be live mass voting during the last episode where a lot of casual international fans might not be awake. If you spread your votes out you risk none of your favs getting in. Example, if you give 5 votes to A and 5 votes to B, but C has a dedicated one pick fanbase and he gets 10 you've just lost both your favs to C. But again just my opinion, you do what makes your heart happy. :)

GreenDragon
>>105947707

Ha ha JongWoo, Haruto, Matthew.....I feel you on your dilemma of who to vote for.

Hayat

my one pick is matthew!! i’m scared he might drop even more with the new elimination bc of the say my name drama😫. I need to see the besties in the same group!!😭

zo

Idk my one pick but I’ve been voting for Zhang Hao, Park Hanbin and Seo Won. With Seowon I just wanted him in the final episode at least. I got curious when they showed a glimpse of his audition where he performed attention so I went and watched the full ver on youtube and I feel like this show really hasn’t shown much of his potential

soel

my one pick is matthew!! really worried about his rank so i hope he has a lot of one pick fans...

Isabelle reffas

I’ll team Jiwoong from day one. Fingers crossed for him.

Tabea

My one pick is Zhanghao but I'm really struggling and wish I had a second device because now that Phanbin is actually close to reaching the top 9 I realise how badly I want him to debut and wish I could vote for him too

Bruklyn W.

My one pick is forever Jay. I honestly can’t tell if he’ll make the lineup or not (fingers crossed cause his one pick fanbase is big internationally) but I hope even if he doesn’t debut that he continues to pursue being an idol because he has an amazing voice. I hope he gets snatched up by another company like Hybe or something. I worry a little though because in this age of kpop, he’s seen as older

Gineta Miliukaitė

It's for sure Seunghwan but I am worried he might not make it into the finals.. Imma sob so hard, if that happens... Then probably gonna vote for Matthew

Secretninja312
>>106042601

My 1 pick is also Jay and it has been from the beginning and he's the only one I never moved out of my rotations in voting. To me, I think it wouldn't be surprising for him to be in the final top 9 but at the same time I wouldn't be shocked if he wasn't. He's one of the ones I feel like has a 50/50 shot at making the final group because I think there are a lot of Jay fans out there, but there are also a lot of haters too. I really hope he does make it though. Of my picks, Chen KuanJui is like my "reach" pick. I really want him in the final group, I think he's an amazing performer, entertaining to watch, and has shown to be a good leader too. I know his chances aren't high but I hope people start noticing him again and he has a sudden rise.

MJ

JAY HAS BEEN MY FAVE EVER SINCE THE 1ST EPISODE

jeffavenue
>>105997041

ohh this makes sense. i’m probably only gonna rotate between 2 people then. good thing i’m in asia during the finale so i can be awake for the finale

jeffavenue
>>105958574

i agree. the performances in the earlier episode would give a lot more time for people to vote for

jeffavenue
>>105926142

oh wow that’s so awesome of hao! wish we saw that part :( like no one would know about these kinda things if people don’t watch outside of the broadcast

melina malfoy

moi mes choix au tout début etait sung han bin , kim ji woon , kim gyu vin , lee ho taek , park gun wook , han yu jin, yoo seung eon , zhang hao et keita . Mais maintenant c'est sung han bin , zhang hao, keita , ricky, kim ji woon , lee ho taek , park gun wook, kim tae rae et en dernier à egalité pour moi sont han yu jin , kim gyu vin, yoo seung eon et na kamden

Laila 💛

Jeff always knows the ranks, I'm always impressed about how he can predict it hahaha But, talking about my one pick, I love Sung Hanbin since the first episode and it is unchangeable, however, I fell in love for many of this guys, like, at this moment, I'm in love with Park Hanbin and I really wish we have Park Gunwook in the final top 9... Also, I looove Jongwoo. There's just so many of them that I love, including the ones that already got eliminated... The amount of talent and personality of this cast is amazing, I'm glad I'm currently watching it, while we have the opportunity to vote for them.

Rach

My one pick is going to be Yoon Jongwoo for sure. He's done nothing but improve during his time on BP and shown that he has the skill set and mentality to be in the group. I've always been voting for him alongside Hui and Jiwoong and it breaks my heart to not be able to give them all equal love after the final elimination but I think Jongwoo has really fought tooth and nail and deserves it. He hasn't had a benefit since Back Door and has still been rising despite some of the hate he's been receiving. I want to see him succeed. And if he can do it with Hui and Jiwoong then that's even better lmao

Neeko
>>106042601

The kid is gonna be a star regardless. He's my number 1 pick too but even if he doesn't debut in this group for whatever reason, that voice is going places and everybody knows it!

Day

My one pick is Keita 🫡

Jerin

Watching this 2 months late, but my one pick was and is Zhang Hao.

Nelle M

All I'll say is I definitely think Matthew has gotten some much needed PR lessons since the show lmao. This definitely didn't show him in the best light, and not everything can be boiled down to evil editing all the time, esp as a PD pick.