Maggie’s Blackmail Begins Ch. 03 (Patreon)

I don’t remember exactly what time I woke up the next day, but my parents had already left and there were a few messages left by Derek on my phone. It seems that I was going to have a surprise coming to my house today, sometime around noon. I was instructed to not let it wait on the front porch, to wear the sundress Kaylee picked out for me and nothing else for the rest of the day.

I took off my comfy hoodie, the only thing I was still wearing and began getting ready for this exciting surprise. I started by taking a hot shower to help me wake up, and shaved because I wanted to feel nice and smooth. It took me some time finding the dress from the trip. It wasn’t like I was ever planning on wearing it, so why not just leave it in my closet.

The dress was annoying to put on, it had 10 big buttons running down the back, sleeveless and had a tie at the top that went behind my neck to hold it up. Basically, it was a fancy form-fitting apron with buttons. It felt weird wearing it with no underwear, I felt a little exposed with how thin the material was, like walking around in a long sleeveless t-shirt and nothing else. I didn’t have long to get used to it because there was a sudden knock at the door and I excitedly ran to the front of the house.

I opened the door to find a very tall, handsome, well-dressed man standing in front of my door and for a second I thought I won some kind of sweepstakes.

“Hi, Maggie,” I was caught a little off guard that he knew my name, but I guess Derek did set this up, “may I come in.”

“Yes, please,” I felt very vulnerable allowing him in, between the only thin material covering my body and our big difference in height, I didn’t know what to expect.

“Do you remember me, Maggie?”

I looked at him kind of confused, I don’t think I ever met him in my life.

He gave off a slight laugh and said, “well I guess you wouldn’t remember me, I was wearing a mask,” he paused, reached down, undid his zipper, and pulled out his massive cock.

“Oh my…” I was almost embarrassed that I knew exactly who he was by his penis alone, “Benjamin.”

I felt his hand on my head as he brought it towards his hardening cock and I instinctively opened my mouth to accept it. He only allowed the tip to enter and held me there, it was almost as if he was showing me my place. I was his to use, this wasn’t about me, it was all about his enjoyment.

“Your brother-in-law and I have been talking and I told him I was going to be down for business, he had a devious idea that he thought I would find entertaining.”

He pulled my mouth off of his cock, “now show me to your room.”

I stood back up, unable to take my eyes off of his beautiful penis, I missed it since that day and had been craving it inside of me ever since. I walked him into my room and he made himself right at home opening up one of my windows and looking outside before turning around, his eyes scanning over my body.

“We’re going to play a little game, you are going to bend out of that window, I’m going to close the curtains around your waist,” he walked up to me putting a hand below my chin and raising my head to look into his eyes, “now everything outside of that window is going to be the nicest, sweetest, innocent little girl, saying hi to everyone that passes by and knows nothing but complete honesty,” he reached down and put his hand under my skirt, toying with my pussy, and whispered in my ear “behind the curtain, you are my dirty little slut, who gets exactly what she deserves.”

He knew exactly what he was doing to me, his middle finger slightly entering me, again, just the tip, wiggling it around, “mmmm, yes sir.”

“Now if the innocent girl ignores anyone or lies, she’s going to get punished by one of these little buttons getting undone, think of them as the bridge between the princess and the slut, until there is nothing but an exposed slut hanging outside a window for all to see.”

If he undid all of the buttons, there would be nothing left but the tie behind my neck holding it up, once that was undone, it would just be a piece of cloth falling off of my body and to make my nervousness worse, it was a beautiful Saturday outside.

“Ready for some fun, princess?”

“Yes Sir,” I said nervously.

All I needed to do was be nice, and I’m a nice person, what’s the worst that could happen I thought to myself. Benjamin led me to the window he had prepared, making me bend over and lean outside, I felt the curtains around the window close around me and bind together. I felt my legs and ass slowly exposed as the back of my dress was raised. Even with the curtain I still felt very exposed.

“I’ve missed this delicious little pussy for months now,” I heard him say behind the curtain, feeling his breath on the back of my leg.

“I bet you, oh god,” I looked down trying to hide the look on my face as I felt his tongue lick my pussy from top to bottom rather suddenly, the tip entering me as he did.

God his tongue felt so good, I haven’t had anyone eat my pussy since that day and I forgot how incredible it felt. The softness of his tongue, the warmth coming off of his mouth, the feeling of the air hitting my lips from his breathing, there was really nothing else like it. Now if this all was for his enjoyment; this feeling must have been my payment. Payment I thought to myself, did that make me a whore?

I was losing track of everything from the pussy licking going on behind the curtain. I could only imagine what it looked like, as a man was kneeling behind me licking my pussy. It wasn’t until I heard some people talking that I remembered exactly what was going on. Of all people who had to pass by, it was my high school crush Brian with the “popular” crowd, Erica, Natalie, Paul, and Scott. Paul and Scott were on the football team with Brian. Erica and Natalie were cheerleaders and for some reason, Erica always made it her mission to try to make my life miserable when we were in school together.

I quickly yelled out, “He..llo!” My voice breaking as I said it, rather embarrassingly.

Brian turned and saw me, “Hey!” Waving as he said it and turning back around continuing on his way.

I could still hear them as they kept walking because they were talking rather obnoxiously loud, probably so that I could still hear their mocking.

“Who was that Brian,” Erica said, “one of your groupies?”

I blushed when I heard that and inwardly wishing I was only so lucky that Brian would do anything with me.

“She’s that girl that hangs out with the stoners,” Paul said.

“Wait, that was a girl? I thought they were all guys,” Natalie said laughing.

“I bet they all get stoned and bang her,” was the last thing I heard before they were out of earshot.

The thought made me blush, my friends all fucking me and the idea made me wet.

It wasn’t long before the next passerby came and obviously, it had to be my neighbor, Mr. Robin, out walking his dog and you knew he was going to talk to me.

“Hi, Mr. Robin! Out walking Max today?” I said smiling the best I could.

I felt Benjamin move from licking my pussy to slowly pushing his fingers inside of me.

“Yup, the old boy needed a walk, and so did the dog,” he said laughing at his own joke, “what are you doing just hanging outside your window?”

“Oooo,” Benjamin was doing everything he could to get me to moan while Mr. Robin was talking to me, “oh, just getting some fresh air on such a beautiful day,” my lip quivering a little as I said it and feeling a button being undone on my dress since that was obviously a lie.

What was I supposed to say, getting eaten and fingered while I talked to random people passing by hoping they didn’t know what dirty, slutty things were happening behind this curtain? That would have gone over really well, I didn’t realize how hard the truth was to say around people that knew me. A part of me almost wanted to honestly say that and it made my nipples hard just imagining his reaction.

Only 9 buttons and the tie were holding the dress together and I was starting to realize how easily lying came rather than saying the truth.

“Being a good girl today, Magpie?” He said with an odd smirk.

I almost heard Benjamin giggle behind me at the question and in my head, I was laughing as well, a good girl would never be doing what I was right now.

“Yes sir, I’m always on my best behavior,” I felt another button being undone, now only leaving 8 intact.

“Hopefully the boys are treating you with plenty of respect, I’d hate to think some bad little boy is treating my adopted niece poorly.”

Benjamin gave my butt a firm little slap, nudging me forward a little. I hoped that Mr. Robin didn’t notice the sudden movement, but at his age, I doubt he would notice a nuclear bomb going off.

“Boys? No, sir, boys don’t even notice me.” I couldn’t stop lying for some reason and the buttons were going one by one, now only leaving 7.

I was starting to get close as the fingering assault on my pussy continued, causing my toes to curl into the carpet and the involuntary biting of my lip.

“By the way Magpie, that reminds me, your parents wanted me to remind them about the pie festival this year, are you coming?”

“No, but I’m breathing hard,” I said only really hearing the last three words.

“What was that Maggie?” he asked not really understanding what I had just said.

“I’m not sure, mmmm, yet it depends on if I decide to get, oh, a summer job or not.”

“Don’t worry about that, just let me know if you want to come or not and I’ll make sure it happens.”

“Yes, yes I want to cum,” I bit my lip as I said the word cum.

My cheeks were flushed, my breathing was ragged, I was on the edge of an orgasm, and I could only imagine how wet I was. Mr. Robin walked up to me and put his hand on my forehead.

“Are you feeling well Magpie, you look like you are coming down with something.”

“I’m fine… just not used… all of this fresh air,” his touch felt so good, I wanted him to touch me more.

“You feel a little warm, are you sure everything is ok?”

“Just fine Uncle Jim, just fine, nothing going on here,” two buttons were undone and most of my dress was now hanging off of my body from the waist down.

Just as I was about to cum, Benjamin stopped fingering me and left me a hot boiling mess needing release, badly. My first thought was Mr. Robin’s cock inches away from me. I could so easily reach up and have it out before he even knew what was going on. Thankfully, Max started pulling on his leash, obviously needing his own release.

“Well, got to keep going or Max is going to pull my arm off, if you need anything at all, just let me know Magpie,” he said giving me a strong hug.

“That’s ok Uncle Jim, I’m good,” another button was undone, did he know what I was thinking?

As Mr. Robin walked away, I tried to reach down and touch myself but Benjamin smacked my hand, stopping me and undoing another button only leaving 3.

“Why another button? I didn’t lie?” I said rather frustrated for having followed the rules.

“Remember what I said princess, good girl on that side, slut on this side, the good girl was about to do something dirty, so hence the punishment,” he corrected me giving me another spanking.

With 3 buttons left, I was starting to get nervous about any other lie that may come out of my mouth. People passed by and I made sure to say hi to everyone, not wanting to give Benjamin an excuse. The whole time he just teased my clit with the tip of his tongue. Thankfully, it seemed like no one was in the mood to chat, until, a guy around my age was walking by. I said hello and he stopped, giving me a rather confused expression as he walked over to me.

I knew him, his name was… Adam, he was a real nerdy guy that I graduated with, but never actually talked to. He kind of always gave me the creeps, like he was always around watching me.

“Hi, Maggie,” he said with a stutter, sounding really nervous, I guess if you never talked to someone and they suddenly said hi, you’d be a little nervous too.

As he was walking up to me, he tripped on the grass and ended up right in front of me. A little uncomfortably close, I mean his crotch was right in my face and once he noticed he jumped back a little while looking down at me.

He was kind of tall, well compared to me everyone is tall, really thin, he was basically as people would say, a bean pole.

“What are you up to Maggie?”

I was trying to figure out the best thing to say, but my mind suddenly focused on what was going on behind me, Benjamin was rubbing the tip of his cock up and down my wet slit.

“Just, taking…a lazy day, you know, how that is,” I said with the fakest smile I could muster and felt another button undone leaving me at just two, I hoped that Adam didn’t see the hand sneak up my back to undo it.

I was starting to feel very exposed; I could feel the sun on my lower back. But that wasn’t my biggest concern, my concern was the cock now very slowly penetrating my pussy. I must have made a weird grunting sound as I was being penetrated because Adam gave me a concerned look.

“Are you ok Maggie? What’s going on?”

“Nothing, just a little sore from my run this morning,” another button released and only one was left, the release loosening the top of the dress. I could feel more of the sun now hitting my exposed back and from this angle, I wasn’t sure what Adam could see.

Benjamin was almost all the way inside of me, he was so long and thick, it hurt but felt good at the exact same time, my brain was slowly going, buh bye.

“Hey Maggie, can I just be honest with you?”

“Yeah, sure, speak your mind.”

“Why did you say hi to me, I didn’t even think you noticed me.”

The cock inside of me, now slick with my juices, began slowly pulling out of me and just as slowly penetrating me again, giving me the slowest fuck, I’d ever felt in my life.

“I... noticed you,” my cheeks and chest were starting to turn red and the final button was undone only leaving the tie to hold my dress up. 

I crossed my arms over my chest hoping to keep it covered as my back was now fully exposed, but thankfully Adam having knelt down in next to me couldn’t possibly see my back.

He took my right hand into his and said, “I noticed you too,” holding my hand tight into his.

Benjamin, pushed a finger into my ass causing me to grip Adam’s hand tight and a slight moan to escape my lips. I was almost naked, being fucked, had a finger penetrating my ass and the nerdiest guy in school was hitting on me, what was going on here?!?!

“I like you, Maggie, I have since the first moment I saw you, I just never had the guts to talk to you,” Adam was now the one blushing and squeezing my hand, “you’re just so pretty and even though no one else seemed to notice, very sexy.”

The cock inside of me was going faster now and I was trying my best not to rock back and forth, making it noticeable what was going on behind the curtain.

“Thank you,” was all I could say, my breath became a little ragged as I could feel my orgasm starting to build.

“Can I…kiss you,” Adam said rather silently out of the blue.

Benjamin tapped my back twice almost as a signal to say yes, I didn’t know if that was what he wanted and then he tapped again. I couldn’t do it, I couldn’t kiss him, not while this was all going on, it was just too much. Then I felt my ass get pinched hard and it stung.

“Yes,” popped out of my mouth, trying to make it sound as normal as possible.

He clumsily leaned forward pressing his lips up against mine, his hand letting go of mine and running his fingers through my hair to the back of my head. His other hand began moving up to my face but accidentally brushed against my sensitive left nipple causing me to moan into his mouth. His hand stopped and to my shock, I felt his hand grab my left boob and began groping it. He must have thought he won the lottery since I didn’t stop him or push him away, but I really didn’t know what to do.

“Mmmm,” I began moaning, but it wasn’t Adam, it was Benjamin now rubbing my clit as he was fucking me, he knew exactly how to push my buttons and I was worried that Adam was getting the wrong idea.

Adam’s hand went from the back of my head to my bareback, and around pushing my dress aside and exposing my bare right breast. Nothing was holding him back anymore as his left hand joined in causing the dress to bunch between my tits completely exposing me and his hands groping my chest. He finally stopped kissing me and began kissing his way down the side of my face to my neck, crudely groping my breasts as he did.

“God, I’ve wanted this for the longest time, I didn’t imagine this would ever happen,” Adam said while breathing hard on my neck, “I never knew you were like this.”

“Mmmm, you have no idea,” my filters were now gone, I was in the moment, “you have no idea.”

Adam suddenly stood up, looked around, unzipped his shorts and pulled out his cock. For such a tall guy, not everything matched. Without even asking he placed his hands on the side of my head and pushed it into my mouth just as it was opening to moan. I was being taken on both sides and only two out of the three people knew what was going on.

“This is the furthest I’ve ever gotten with a girl,” Adam said while thrusting his cock in and out of my mouth, “I thought of you, like this so many nights.”

I blushed thinking about him jacking off at night, calling out my name as he came into a sock, I could only imagine his dirty little fantasies of me. At the same time, Benjamin was taking no mercy ramming his cock into me and I could no longer hold back the sounds of pleasure, moaning on the cock in my mouth.

At that moment, Adam’s demeanor changed, “I didn’t realize what a slut you were, you looked and acted so innocent, but deep down you’re just a little cock sucker,” he pulled the tie on the back of my neck releasing the last thing holding it to my body and pulled the dress out from under me.

I looked up to see him holding the dress to his face, smelling it, breathing me in as his pace quickened. I was now completely naked and for a split second, I felt I needed to save some modesty and put my hands over my chest to cover myself. Adam wouldn’t allow it and he grabbed my hands holding them up over my head continuing to fuck my mouth. I couldn’t see anything and hoped that no one passing by noticed and the bushes allowed some cover.

“I can’t believe I was in love with such a fucking whore,” Adam now sounding angrier then turned on.

Before I knew what was going on, he took my dress and tied my hands together and then secured them to the drainage pipe to the left of my window, his hands going back down to my head now furiously fucking my mouth. I was lucky that he didn’t have the biggest cock or else he would have been choking me, instead, it just kept hitting the back of my throat, but now I was completely helpless.

“Mmmm, mmmm, oh god, oh god,” I tried to say as I was about to cum.

I felt Benjamin begin to throb inside me and I knew what was about to happen. I felt his hot seed shoot out of his cock, the feeling spreading through my pussy and as I felt some drip out and over my clit, I began to have my own orgasm. Adam pulled out of my mouth and watched as he jerked off his cock in front of me, I couldn’t believe such a nice guy was about to do what he was going to do.

“This is what you want isn’t it,” he said, eyes tightly closed, stroking himself fast and hard, “this is what you,” he stopped, grunted and started spewing cum all over my face.

Not far away I heard clapping and cheering, it was Brian and his friends, I had no idea how long they had been standing there watching. Adam quickly put his dick back into his pants and ran off embarrassed, I, on the other hand, wasn’t as lucky, helplessly tied up and exposed at my window. I didn’t even realize that Benjamin was no longer inside me as well, in fact, I had no idea where he had gone.

“Well, I guess we definitely know she’s a girl now and a real dirty one it seems, just your type Brian,” Scott said.

If it wasn’t bad enough that they could all see me, cum on my face, breasts exposed, they started pulling out their phones. I started to panic, pulling on my dress, trying to free myself but even with such thin material, I couldn’t rip it and free myself.

“Please don’t, please don’t take pictures of me,” I begged and pleaded which just caused them to laugh and get closer.

Erica knelt next to me and taking a selfie with me, I did my best to look away but she held me by my chin forcing me to look at the camera. Tears starting to form in my eyes, it was one thing being exposed in another state, another to be almost caught, but these were people I knew, people I went to school with and now they were getting evidence of my true nature, and soon everyone was going to know.

“I want to get a pic with my cock in her mouth,” Paul said.

“Ew, gross, it’s covered in nerd cum,” Natalie said, the sound of disgust in her voice.

“I can fix that,” I didn’t know what Brian meant until I saw him open up a bottle of water and start pouring it all over my head.

“Cold!” the water was freezing, I could feel it drip down my face, chest and down my back and before I could close my mouth a cock was quickly put into it.

More pictures were taken, the girls took selfies like they were posing with some celebrity, striking poses, playing with my nipples, reaching inside my room and spanking my ass. I looked up to see Paul was recording the whole thing with his dick still in my mouth and I couldn’t help but start crying.

“Awe the little slut is crying, I thought she liked being the center of attention,” Erica sounding like the cruel bitch I knew she was and when I thought she couldn’t get any worse, she crawled past me into my room, found my phone and crawled back outside.

She held my thumb to the phone and unlocked it and started taking pictures of me. She took photos of every inch of me, from my cock filled mouth down to my feet, she had it all. I felt Paul’s cock start to throb and couldn’t believe he was about to cum so fast. I prepared myself for it and quickly started swallowing the stream that came out, but realized too late that he was peeing. I couldn’t swallow it all and some started coming out of my mouth as I coughed feeling like I was drowning in urine.

“Please, please let me go, you can keep the pictures, just don’t show anyone, please, I’ll do whatever you want,” I begged not knowing what I was begging for, for them not to show anyone, to let me go, I didn’t know.”

Erica turned to Brian, “I know you’ve always wanted to put it in my butt, but I won’t let you, how about you put it in hers?”

Everyone came into my room except Erica, who untied my hands, but not before putting her hand around my throat and making sure I was looking at her right in the eyes, “we’ll let you go, but first, you have to be a good little slut and do what we want, or else.”

Erica finally came in and they had me bend over my bed, I heard a zipper undone and when I looked back to see what was going on, I saw Erica on her knees sucking on Brian’s cock. When she noticed me looking, she gave me a wink and his cock a few strokes and led him over to my ass. She put the tip at my hole and he tried to push forward, but it was too dry for him to get in and it started to hurt.

“Awe too bad we don’t have any lube, maybe this will help,” Natalie bent over my butt and she spit on his cock and I could feel it drip down my ass crack.

It didn’t help at all, but that didn’t stop Brian from continuing to try. He felt so thick and big that I thought he was going to tear me apart, I guess it got too frustrating for him, so he pulled out and plunged it as deep as he could into my wet pussy.

“Oh god!” the sudden penetration was intense.

“The bitch is soaking wet and loving it, you guys need to get in on this shit,” Brian waiving his friends over.

Paul quickly jumped on the bed laying down, as Brian pulled out of me, hands were all over me, positioning me on top of Paul, forcing me to straddle his lap and lowering me onto his cock. None of this was gentle or slow, they wanted to use me and it was going to be rough. Brian came behind me and this time his wet cock had a much easier time sliding into my ass. Scott got in front of me, his dick, the biggest of them all, started forcing his way into my mouth. The feeling was overwhelming, between the sudden gangbang I was getting, the exposure, the ridicule, and humiliation, I was bombarded with intense stimulation both mentally, emotionally and physically. As three familiar people were using me for the first time, my mind was going in dozens of directions.

What if they show people, what if they post it, what if my parents find out, what if, what if, what if my life was now ruined. What if everyone finds out what a slut I really am? I looked up to see Erica still with my phone in her hand, pointing it at me and Natalie watching her from behind with a hand over her mouth, either in shock or to stop from laughing, or both, I couldn’t tell.

“Tell me when you guys are ready, I want to get her expression,” Erica said with a smirk on her face.

“I’m close, I’m going to fill this slut with my cum,” Brian said from behind.

“Me too,” Paul said underneath me.

“I’m cumming!” The first words Scott said this whole time as he started cumming in my mouth, but then pulled out and start shooting on my face.

“Let me fill that ass,” were Brian’s last words as I felt him unload inside of me, my eyes wide at the sudden sensation and then both Scott and Brian got off of the bed and behind Natalie to see what she was doing.

Through all of this my body’s natural instinct started to take over, and I was getting close to cumming.

“Bounce for me slut, bounce on my cock, the faster I cum, the faster this is over with,” Paul said underneath me.

“Yes sir,” was all I could manage to say as I started riding his cock, “mmmm, are you getting close?”

“Yeah that’s right baby, show me your dirty side, tell me how much you like my cock.”

“I like your cock, mmmm, it feels so good inside of me,” I said trying to sound sexy licking at the cum Scott left on my face.

“Where do you want me to cum, beg for it, rub your tits as you do.”

I moved my hand to my breasts massaging them, “please, I want to feel your hot cum inside me, please fill me with your hot delicious cum.”

That was the last thing Paul needed to hear before filling me, grunting and grabbing my ass as he did, the shots of cum pushing me over the edge as well.

“I’m cumming!” came out of my mouth as I did.

“That was great Maggie, more than I ever expected, don’t worry we deleted all the pictures we had,” Erica was saying, an evil smirk on the corner of her mouth and at the same time beeps and other sounds coming off of my phone, “your fans, on the other hand, are loving the pictures on your Facebook,” my heart stopped, “and the live public feed we were just showing as a couple hundred were watching you get gangbanged.”

Paul pushed me off of him and onto the bed, I was in complete shock unable to move, just laying on my back looking at the ceiling with tears flowing from my eyes. They eventually put their dicks away and left my room except for Erica. I could hear my phone start to ring.

“Looks like mommy is calling, let me get that for you,” she accepted the call, “Hello Mrs. Hill, this I a friend of your daughter,” she looked down at me and smiled, “oh she’s right here, let me give her the phone.”

“Maggie!” I could hear my mom yelling through the phone as Natalie began to rub my pussy with the corner of it and then start to press it into me, I felt myself being spread and as I looked down, she had pushed my phone halfway inside of me, “Maggie!”

With one last hard shove, it was all the way inside of me, “Maggie!”

I jerked up, looking around, there was no one in my room, I was still wearing my hoodie from yesterday, my mom was yelling my name.

“Come on sleepyhead, I know you don’t have school, but it doesn’t mean you can’t sleep the day away!”

It was all just a dream.