Home Artists Posts Import Register

Poll

Dr Stone Replacement Poll

  • Delicious in Dungeon 550
  • Mashle 246
  • The Eminence in Shadow 361
  • Undead Unluck 184
  • 2024-02-19
  • —2024-02-22
  • 1341 votes
{'title': 'Dr Stone Replacement Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Delicious in Dungeon', 'votes': 550}, {'text': 'Mashle', 'votes': 246}, {'text': 'The Eminence in Shadow', 'votes': 361}, {'text': 'Undead Unluck', 'votes': 184}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 2, 22, 15, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 2, 19, 17, 27, 23, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allows_multiple': True, 'total_votes': 1341}

Content

We're coming up on the end of Dr Stone, so it's time for another poll!  As such we'll be getting this poll done in advance, so we all know what's coming next.

Vote for YOUR FAVORITE show that you would like to see us react to! We always take note of which shows get plenty of votes, but don't win. Whichever gets the most votes we will release early access reactions on the Saturday when the final Dr Stone reaction goes public.

NOTE: Jacob and I have not seen any of these anime!

Thank you all so much for your continued generous support!

If you don't recognize a show, check out the AniList links below:

Dungeon Meshi (Delicious in Dungeon) · AniList
MASHLE (MASHLE: MAGIC AND MUSCLES) · AniList
Kage no Jitsuryokusha ni Naritakute! (The Eminence in Shadow) · AniList
Undead Unluck · AniList

Comments

Cameron Hall

We winning regardless

TheFihr

Dsmn good choices, but I really wanna see the bros reaction on Cids cringe

D4C

well this is a "vote all" poll they would certainly enjoy dungeon meshi the most though

Cryogenx37

Oh boy oh boy yee

Canadian_Caesar

Eminence in Shadow is peak, hope it gets its own reaction series soon even if it ends up losing this poll.

Alba Zawa

Pretty fun poll ngl Eminence please 🙏 shadow-sama the goat.

Kelokonda

Good shows all around

Big Fuze

Mash le is literally an anime made for your type of humor

Sera

I can't believe people are sleeping on Mashle so much ;-; Oh well, Dungeon Meshi is fun too.

Kor of the Son

Hope Mashle wins at some point because they would love it.

lilmarsha

Dungeon Meshi is a really good one

関口信玄

Damn, I want all of them lmao.

Davies

Lets go Dungeon Meshi!

LaconicKibitz

The Voting has begun. The poll is live. We have 3 days remaining.

James Ancester

Would love eminence, but I'm not sure if (hopefully not presuming too much) if the bros have seen enough isekai or even really enjoy the baseline of the genre enough to also like a parody of it.

CaffieneKitty

Mashle is such fun it’s great to see it on a poll! I’ve also been looking for a reason to watch Eminence though as I have heard it’s pure crack.

kingofshibainu

Eminence! It's so stupid it's great

Colin

Undead Unluck has absolutely fascinating world building, fun characters and good action but I've been somewhat disappointed in the second half of the anime so far, mostly due to excessive recaps and filler each week. It's unfortunate because they had me in the first half. I'm probably just going to read the manga at this point because everyone says it's good. Either way it's a shame that more people aren't talking about this series. We have Hulu/Disney to thank for that once again.

Gundeep Singh

Where is solo levelling and ninja kamui?

XWF Outlaw

Delicious in Dungeon: 24 Episodes (Current Seasonal) The Eminence in Shadows: 32 Episodes (Ongoing) Mashle: Magic & Muscles: 24 Episodes (Current Seasonal) UnDead UnLuck: 24 Episodes (Current Seasonal)

LPK675

They've already read Solo Leveling, so I imagine they're not in a rush to watch the anime adaptation.

camel.d

eminence in shadows for me

Edrei Z.

I mean as fans of D&D, it's gotta be Dungeon Meshi because that's literally a food show wrapped in Fantasy goodness.

Tsuki Wolf

Seconded from Edrei. DnD fans need to watch Dungeon Meshi just for the fun haha

Woodsie89

I didn't realize Delicious was that popular... I found it kind of repetitive, lol. Was sure when I clicked on the poll it was going to be between undead and eminence.

Feel Z. Crux

Good lord this Poll is full of peak. Hoping the ones that don't make it will return, since I'm fairly confident all of these are up the Bros alley.

backseat

UU dropping balls in between the two polls because of the anime pacing, david production did the show dirty

Rosinenbomber

Well the polling for eminence made me sub to Patreon. I would love for a reaction to it

Drax

Take Undead Unluck out of the poll and put in Space brothers

Lufttwafe

How in the world Eminence in Shadow is losing god damn it. Delicious in Dungeon is not worth watching at all, an other waste of several months reacting to mid show.

BeesKnees

Delicious in Dungeon is the obvious choice here. Bros are huge D&D nerds and they will love the world building in this show. Great comedy and production so far too.

晏霆 周

Looks like Eminence is losing, but hope that they will react to it someday! Such a extremely fun show. Unfortunately I don't get the appeal of Dungeon Meshi.

Morringhan

It's sad that Mashle won't be the winner

L.C.

how the hell is delicious in dungeon winning

Rea

dungeon meshi would be really fun for them imo, and the story really picks up later in the manga so there's more than just good food and dnd style hijinks to look forward to

BeesKnees

They're watching Space brothers after Nana so no need to put it in a poll. It'll come in about 6 months when Nana is over.

Ran

Cause it's the best fit for them, considering the kind of shows they enjoy the most.

Ran

Honestly, besides a fantastic pilot episode, the anime really doesn't live up to the manga. I definitely recommend reading it if you're looking for a very action heavy rom/com.

Ran

Btw, what happened to Mushishi? I know it got the most votes in the September gauntlet poll, but seeing they're reacting to Nana atm, I guess they didn't pick it. I don't mind if they're watching Space Brothers after Nana either, but I'd really love them to watch Mushishi at one point.

Ran

I feel the same way about Eminence in Shadow. Actually no, I do get the appeal, but it's just not my cup of tea.

SoClose

Eminence overrated trash, stopped being interesting after the first ep and just turned into a generic harem isekai. DD is just weeb trash. Mash & Undead are at least fun generic trash. But these choices are straight doodoo. Ya'll could be doing Now and then Here and There, or Tatami Galaxy...

Alec Hagen

Mashle should be chosen for the 2nd OP alone (also its just dumb fun)

fElBiTeR :V

I'm so sad Undead Unluck will never see the light of day :')

Payam Sharifi

Will it start to really pick up within this 24 episode season you think? Not that I mind it as is, I was a little underwhelmed at first but pretty much every episode I love more than the previous (and there's clearly a lot of potential for it to keep improving).

Rea

Hmm, not sure. It's not a super long series and they're mostly doing a one chap = one ep thing...so without spoiling anything I'd anticipate by ep 24 we'll get something good ;)

Oscar0724

Could you add Dennou-Coil on the next pool? 電脳コイル https://anilist.co/anime/2164/Dennou-Coil/

Old Man Jacan

It'll just become the next assassination classroom, there forever before finally getting its time to shine

Old Man Jacan

Have the bros said anything about possibly reacting to Blue Eye Samurai? I know its not technically anime but its just like Arcane in that sense and its also absolutely amazing

Ica

The pace has been 2 or occasionally 3 chapters per episode.

Rea

Ah, my bad, didnt bother going back to the chaps to check, I just know the pace has been pretty decent, especially considering some adaptations which pad things out a lot

Zairaner

And they are still putting currently airing shows onto the polls with non-currently airing shows. At least all of these are very new.

Ica

They're all so new that I don't think it matters. Eminence aired just last season.

DeetsViBre

I am so Happy Dungeon Meshi is probably next. I was so taken with the show (in english no less) I read the entire Manga and it was amazing.

Fenronin (Dorian Dubourg)

worst takes I've ever seen how is Undead Unluck generic with this kind of worldbuilding but it's not like I can take we can take seriously someone calling everything trash.

KaregoAt

Dunmeshi is great, I'm happy if it gets chosen.

SoClose

How is it generic? Are you out of your gotdamn mind? How about you think about it for a second. And yes DD is weeb trash. Boring one at that.

Galefarce61

Since it looks like DM is going to win, im going to highly suggest the dub. Its fantastic and one of the main cast is voiced by SungWon Cho AKA ProZD

Taycen Timothy

I’d like to see To Your Eternity season 2 at least make a poll

Jack Olsen

Dungeon Meshi is genuinely incredible, you guys are gonna love it!

Ica

Oh please no. I'm so excited about a DunMeshi reaction but would absolutely not watch a reaction to the dub.

Perazok

I strongly recommend the dub for delicious in the dungeon

J

ep4 of the dub is weirdly racist about the orcs tho (mixing AAVE with caveman speech..)

Perazok

I only watched a little bit in sub and dub and stopped after I saw this poll so I wouldn’t know. The main characters are great though.

Zairaner

Oh it definitely does matter a lot. Just less than usual. Even just being in its second cour already (like undead unluck, and eminence s2) does matter. Though probably not enough to change te outcome.

Marta Kira Ayanami

Voted for food in dungeons. Also. Can't wait for more medicine kitty eps. The brothers must be double inversely clairvoyant.

Anonimowy Gaal

I know it's pretty toxic to think that, but I'm glad The Eminence didn't win that xD DiD is going to be amazing to experience with bros on the other hand.

Saiden

Delicious in Dungeon is good and I know the brothers will enjoy it, but I really hope Eminence gets a slot cause it's just so fun.